Showing posts with label pyroclastic flows. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pyroclastic flows. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Guess this means it's columnar jointing week

Well, since everyone else is getting in on the columnar jointing meme/festival/whatever, I suppose I could throw a few photos out there...

Columns in an ignimbrite on the east side of Santa Maria volcano in Guatemala. (A drive-by, unfortunately. I would have loved a close-up look at these!)


Some of the oldest volcanics in the Vulsini volcanic district, Italy: a jointed trachyte from the Bolsena caldera complex. (The tree at the top of the cliff is about 3 m tall.) This is one of my favorite photos, because you can see multiple cooling sets divided by fractures - and it really emphasizes how columns form from inward-directed cooling.


Willow Mountain, Terlingua, Texas (near Big Bend). Beautiful columnar jointing throughout. (No scale on this one, but I'd say it's about 200 meters from top to base.)


And, finally, an actual example of columnar jointing in basalt, which is probably much more common than jointing in an any of the other stuff I've mentioned: a lava flow near St. George, Utah. (Wish I could figure out where, but Google Earth isn't helping today. Has anyone seen this abandoned water tank?)


Perhaps we should submit a request for a Columnar Jointing Week to someone in Washington. As far as I can tell, we're sadly lacking in geological observances anyway...

Monday, September 20, 2010

Distinguishing deposits from andesitic eruptions

Telling apart different kinds of deposits associated with volcanic eruptions isn't always easy. There are a lot of factors that can affect their appearance: the location and type of eruption, the magma/lava type, where they're emplaced, etc. On Montserrat, volcanologists are lucky to have both ancient and modern deposits; they can look at what's currently being erupted and compare it to the older volcanics on the island. We did quite a bit of this on our field trip, and one of our assignments was to summarize the characteristics of andesitic eruption deposits on Montserrat. (I emphasized that because the characteristics we saw are not necessarily going to be the same for all volcanic eruptions, or even for all andesitic eruptions. I've tried to generalize a bit, but apply these cautiously if you're going into the field to look at other volcanic deposits; things may look very different in your field area.)

Block and ash flows are a kind of pyroclastic density current. "Pyroclastic flow" is a kind of catchall term, but there are more specific ones that better describe the makeup of one of these currents. "Block and ash flow" implies that the flow is composed of blocks (either of denser lava or pumice or both) and ash; "pumice flow" means that the contents are mainly pumice and ash, "ash flow" that there are few blocks and mostly ash in the current.

Faint reverse grading in a block and ash flow deposit at Old Road Bay
Block and ash flows contain a range of clast sizes from mm-sized ash to m-scale boulders. The clasts are usually somewhat angular and tend to be a combination of lithics (lava) and pumice. The matrix of these deposits (what larger clasts are embedded in) is generally ashy and may be crystal-rich. The deposit may be clast or matrix supported (which describes whether there is enough matrix that the clasts are not touching) and poorly sorted (clasts are not separated by size). Oxidation and alteration of clasts as well as fractured blocks (including radially jointed clasts) may occur if the flow is deposited into water and cools quickly. Sometimes you can see grading in the deposits (i.e., a change from small to large clasts, or the reverse), which has to do with the energy of the pyroclastic current and the conditions under which clasts are being deposited from it.

Pointing out matrix in a deposit on the side of the Belham River Valley
Debris avalanches form from older volcanic material that's unstable enough to collapse, either because of erosion or alteration or both. They form "hummocky" deposits that are very obvious in aerial photos, but in cross section they're also fairly easy to identify.

Panorama of a debris avalanche deposit near Jack Boy Hill. Different colors mark chunks of preserved stratigraphy.
Debris avalanche deposits contain mm to m sized clasts (or larger), as well as chunks of material from older deposits that retain their original stratigraphy. These clasts and chunks are poorly sorted, and rounded to angular in shape. Clast compositions are almost always mixed, and the matrix is often clayey and highly altered. Jigsaw jointing is apparent in individual clasts, with clast fragments separated by matrix material but orientation with respect to neighboring clasts preserved. Clasts or deposit blocks may be "smeared" out into trains or show internal faulting.

A "jigsaw" fractured block in a debris avalanche deposit
Lahars form when water mixes with volcanic material and flows downslope. These can have the consistency of soup to concrete, and they're a major concern even when a volcano isn't erupting (especially if the volcano is located in a tropical area that gets lots of rain.)

House buried in lahar deposits in the Belham River Valley
Clasts in a lahar deposit range from mm to multi-meter size. They are matrix supported, poorly sorted, and often contain clay or silt in the matrix. The clast shapes vary from rounded to angular and may be either monolithologic (all one rock type) or mixed rock types, depending on the source material. Sometimes the deposits show bedding features such as cross-bedding. There is one absolutely diagnostic feature for lahars: preserved voids where bubbles of air were trapped in the matrix mud. The voids are spherical and usually pretty tiny, but they don't form in pyroclastic currents. (The lack of these voids does not, however, mean that a deposit is not a lahar, so this feature is only useful if it's present.)

Cross-section of a fairly recent lahar deposit. There's not much in the way of sorting or grading here.

A fourth type of pyroclastic current, called a surge, also shows up on Montserrat, but they're not often preserved because they consist of a blast of ash and hot gases (sometimes derived from block and ash flows), and they leave very thin deposits. I don't have any good photos of them, but they tend to be fine-grained (mm to cm sized clasts at the most), and sometimes show cross-stratification. It's rare that they're preserved, especially in a tropical environment, because the fine material washes away very easily.

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

February 2010 dome collapse deposits at Soufriere Hills

If you ever want to visit a post-apocalyptic wasteland, someplace that's been run over by pyroclastic flows would be a great choice. On February 11 of this year, a partial dome collapse on the northeastern flank of the Soufriere Hills lava dome produced spectacular pyroclastic flows, surges, and a 50,000 ft (~15 km) high ash plume. The pyroclastic flows extended the eastern coastline significantly in the area of the old Bramble Airport, and surges were observed flowing out over the ocean on the eastern side of the island.

Here's a photo from the edge of the collapse deposits, below the Jack Boy Hill overlook. In the distance of this photo, you can (just) see a chimney stack. This is one of the only visible structures left in the whole area; even the old Bramble Airport (which would have been visible to the left of the chimney) is now completely buried.


The chimney stack is part of an old sugar mill, and I'm pretty sure that what's visible isn't the whole chimney. To give you a sense of scale, here's yours truly standing next to the stack. 


Walking on pyroclastic deposits isn't difficult, but it's not the most pleasant hike I've taken. Ash is nasty stuff, especially when you're kicking it up whenever you walk somewhere. In addition, these deposits are still(!) quite hot; a few inches down is enough to make it uncomfortable to stand in one place too long, and digging less than a foot down, they become hot to the touch.


Here's what the deposits look like in cross-section. Those dark streaks are degassing structures, which are cut off by the most recent deposits on the top of the sections. 


As I mentioned before, the Montserrat Volcano Observatory scientists brought us on this hike; in the khaki hat and olive shirt is Dr. Paul Cole, the Director of the Observatory. We're examining one of the boulders that was transported downslope in the collapse - and while it looks pretty big, it's actually one of the smaller boulders that we saw. The largest were the size of small houses! (Definitely not something you want to get hit by, which is why it's a good thing that the people on Montserrat pay attention to the exclusion zones.)


On several of the boulders, we saw examples of marks that are interpreted to have been created by the impact and scraping of one boulder against another during transport. They could be described as slickensides, except here they're glassy surfaces that were created very quickly during an impact, rather than slowly during the scraping of a fault surface. (The study I linked to mentions that in the largest marks, frictional melting formed pseudotachylite, which is basically glass.)


Things like the friction marks above, and this next photo, remind you of just how dangerous pyroclastic flows are. Aside from giant boulders smashing into each other, you also get stronger-than-hurricane-force blasts, poisonous gases and extremely high temperatures. To give you an idea of what that does to the landscape, here's a view of the end of a pumice flow lobe that carried trees with it. All the wood here is carbonized; my best guess is that temperatures of around 400°C (or higher!) were involved. That's about twice as hot as your kitchen oven will go.


Did I mention the force involved in pyroclastic flows? Here's an example: a tree limb thicker than my arm that was snapped in half and then pretty much welded into that position. 


Another interesting feature just beyond the pumice lobe were these pit craters, formed when the flow buried a water source, which was then heated to steam and exploded up through the new material.


I think the water in question was probably part of this drainage (this is looking roughly to the west), which we walked down on our way back to the vehicles. While these deposits do retain their heat, there doesn't seem to be enough time to really weld them together, so they're pretty easily washed away by precipitation, and form these sorts of drainage channels.

The channels do make it much easier to see cross-sections, though! There are at least five (probably more) different deposition events represented here, with a lovely pumice-filled channel right in the middle. 



I'll try to get to a post on how to distinguish different types of deposits next (and hey, maybe some annotated photos!)

UPDATE: Claire Howard (one awesome reader) sent in some photos of the factory chimney at Trants from May 1995, 6 months before the beginning of the eruption. Turns out that chimney was a lot taller than it is now. Enjoy - and thanks to Claire!



Monday, March 15, 2010

Looking backward: Past eruptions at Volcán Santa Maria

On our way to visit the Santiaguito Volcano Observatory, Gustavo Chigna of INSIVUMEH (the Guatemalan equivalent of the USGS) was kind enough to take an afternoon off and show us some of the older deposits near Santiaguito. Our first stops were at an exposure of the air-fall deposit from the October 24, 1902 eruption of Volcán Santa Maria. This eruption was a devastating one, stripping the land for more than 50 km around the volcano, burying villages and fincas (plantations) in more than 3 meters of ash, mud and rock, and killing more than 7,000 people (the exact number will probably never be known). The area had already experienced months of earthquakes prior to the eruption, and activity at the crater formed in Santa Maria continued for weeks afterward.


This location is about 4 km from the volcano. The 1902 air-fall deposit here is more than 2 meters thick (the photo is only showing the top bit, and Gustavo is standing a few meters behind the outcrop, so the sense of scale is a bit wonky. The big clast in the center is about fist-sized, though.). This fall deposit contains a mix of lithics (old and new lava and country rock) and pumice, and what's really impressive is that many of the lithics are the same size as the pumice (up to 15 cm). Generally, in a fall deposit the material will have had the same terminal velocity, which means the mass of the pumice and lithics should be roughly equal. Because pumice is much less dense than lithics, this usually means that the lithics are much smaller than the pumice. Possibly the lack of difference in clast sizes here has to do with the proximity to the volcano; in other places that we stopped, the pumices were definitely larger than the lithics.

The view from this location was pretty spectacular, and it highlighted the deposits from the November 2, 1929 dome collapse. Here you can just see the summit of Santa Maria, and the El Brujo and other domes in front of it. Brujo is the dark green dome farthest to the left, and the hummocky low hills in front of it are may be the result of that 1929 collapse. Hummocks are a classic sign of a debris avalanche of some sort, and can be seen in places like Mount St. Helens and Mount Shasta. ***Note: After speaking with Rudiger Escobar, a Santiaguito expert and fellow volcanologist (see the comments section), I wanted to note that the hills pictured here probably have more to do with lava flows coming off of Brujo than older collapse deposits, although some portion of them may be collapse remnants. It's also possible that I have faulty notes, as the conversation was mostly being conducted in Spanish at the time, and my Spanish skills are limited. 



After a bit of backroad driving around the fincas, we reached the Rio Tambor, which was the site of many deaths in the 1929 dome collapse. The 1929 event, in which more than 3 million cubic meters of the lava dome collapsed, was mostly described by foreign geologists who interviewed survivors. Their accounts tell of glowing rains of ash and rock; boiling mudflows in the rivers covered with rafts of glowing rock; a blast that rushed back toward the volcano after it blew down the river valleys, scouring the south side of tree trunks; and people suffocating on gases and hot air. More than 3,000 people were killed, mainly because they were on the fincas for a religious holiday rather than in their villages. Sadly enough, this was a very  minor dome collapse by volcanology standards (a large one might be in the hundreds of millions of cubic meters, such as those at Soufriere Hills on Montserrat).

The coffee plantations that were destroyed in 1929 are no longer here, but the new ones are beginning to encroach. Frankly, I'm not sure I'd want to spend my days working in an area where there are outcrops like this:



These photos are looking east across the Tambor at a mudplain created by lahars, and at the 1902 deposit (the white strip at the base of the cliff) overlain by block-and-ash flow and lahar (volcanic mudflow) deposits. Here the 1902 deposit is about 2 meters thick, and overlain by a thinner gray ashy deposit (perhaps from the 1929 collapse, although it hasn't been well studied and it wasn't clear if that guess was right). The upper blocky deposits are probably post-1929, and consist of a mix of lahar and block-and-ash (pyroclastic flow) leavings.


It was a bit difficult to get a scale into this picture, but the cliff is about 10 meters high, and the bigger boulders at the base are roughly the size of me. This is an interesting photo because it shows a very distinct division between two deposits. What we ended up discussing at this site was what kind of deposits these were, and how to tell them apart. Both block-and-ash flow deposits and lahar deposits look similar at first glance: very poorly sorted, with a clast size range from ash (< 2 mm, in the matrix) to boulders (> 25 cm, supported by the matrix). Both deposits are matrix-supported and both have a bit of a mix of angular and rounded clasts.

So how to tell them apart? One clue might be the angularity of the clasts; block-and-ash flows tend to be a bit more violent in terms of knocking rocks around, and they're dry, which means no muddy cushion for the rocks like a lahar might provide. But what happens if the block-and-ash flow goes down a river (like here)? It could become a lahar, which brings up all sorts of messy discussion about naming conventions. A better indicator of a block-and-ash flow would be the lithology of its clasts; lahars will pick up anything in their path and tend to have a big mix of rock types, while block-and-ash flows tend to be monolithological. Again, however, if a block-and-ash flow travels far enough, it may pick up enough clasts from other places to confuse this.

As it turns out, there is one sure indicator that you've got a lahar deposit, and it's not always easy to find (or present). Because a lahar is a wet flow, it will contain bubbles. When the lahar stops, sometimes those bubbles are unable to rise through the muddy liquid and are trapped; when the deposit dries out, the bubbles leave little spherical cavities in the fine-grained matrix. These are really hard to see and it's easy to debate what you're seeing if you're not sure.

So what was the verdict for these deposits? Based on a bit of arguing discussion, we decided that we were fairly sure we saw bubbles in the lower deposit, but that the upper one had more indicators of a block-and-ash flow deposit. So at this outcrop, we have about 4-5 meters of visible lahar deposits overlain by about 5-6 meters of block-and-ash flow deposits. Needless to say, this would not have been a fun place to have been standing for either event. In fact, Gustavo mentioned that very few people will come down to this area after dark, because some of the victims of the 1929 collapse are thought to haunt the riverbed. Having been down there in the evening, I can attest that it does get a little creepy when it's dark, and it would certainly be easy to turn the jungle sounds into the moaning or wailing of ghosts. Better not to stay there too long, ghosts or no ghosts; it is a channel filled with lahar deposits, after all.

Sunday, August 9, 2009

Degassing structures in pyroclastic deposits

One of my favorite features of the pyroclastic deposits that I saw in Italy were degassing structures. A good field description of these features would be "fines-depleted pipes", since it doesn't make any assumptions about their origins (something to be avoided in the description section of your field notes!)

Branching degassing structures in a pyroclastic deposit in the Colli Albani (Alban Hills) volcanic district. (The ruler is divided into ten-cm sections.)

These pipes are formed when gases trapped in freshly-deposited pyroclastic material rise to the surface of the deposit as overlying material settles and compacts. The gases usually take fines (ash and small lapilli) with them, leaving behind tubes where clast size is larger than the surrounding deposit, and forming fumaroles on the surface of the pyroclastic deposit. The pipes can branch and join, and the ones I've seen range in size from a centimeter or two across to almost half a meter.

Fines-depleted structures galore! The side of the same cliff in the Alban Hills, with geologist headgear for scale.

An annotated version of the last photo, with the outlines of some of the degassing structures and the top of the pyroclastic deposit (overlain by some paleosols and modern soils).

If you look closely at a degassing pipe, you will often see that the clast size gets larger and the abundance of clasts (rather than ash and other fine material) increases as you move toward the edge of the pipe. This is an important clue to the processes going on in the structure; the interpretation here is that gases get concentrated around the edge of a pipe, and blow out more of the fine material there than in the middle.

Detail of the first photo; you can see a strip of scoria and other clasts along the right side of the degassing pipe, and more fine material toward the center.

It kind of brings to mind a push-up popsicle: the melted sherbert oozes up around the edges of the cardboard tube while the stuff in the middle more or less stays put.

(There should really be some oozing in this one to illustrate my point better, but apparently Fred Flintstone only gets excited about non-drippy desserts.)

One of the neatest things about these features is that you can tell something about the emplacement of the deposit. If the degassing pipe cuts through the entire deposit, it's a good bet that the deposit was emplaced all at once, whether as a single unit or through an episode of progressive aggradation. If there are multiple pipes that terminate on different levels of a layered deposit, the layers must represent different episodes in the eruption.

A degassing structure in pyroclastic deposits on Procida Island, near the Bay of Naples. Notice how the bottom of the pipe (which curves around the large central clast) seems to cut off at a layer of cobble sized rocks about a meter and a half above the cliff base. Contemplative volcanologist for scale.

Fines-depleted pipes are an easy way to identify a pyroclastic deposit, and can be a good distinguishing feature if you're trying to tell apart tuffs and lavas (providing there hasn't been so much welding and compaction that the degassing structures are obliterated). Another great example of this is the Valley of Ten Thousand Smokes, an area in Katmai National Park and Preserve (Alaska) that was filled by ash flows from the 1912 eruption of Novarupta.

Southeast up the Valley of Ten Thousand Smokes, with the rim of Katmai Caldera on the left skyline. Photo by R. McGimsey, June 10, 1991; from the USGS Photo Library.

The ash filled the valley to a depth of 200 meters, and both gases trapped in the ash from the eruption and water vapor from buried streams formed thousands of fumaroles on the deposit's surface. (These are no longer active, but still visible on the new valley floor.)