Saturday, February 13, 2010

Roughing it - Guatemala la segunda parte

Yes, I've been hinting at some fieldwork that I'm going to do for the next two weeks - and it's back in Guatemala!



If  you remember the posts I put up last year about my first visit, you'll also remember that quite a bit less science happened than I was hoping, thanks to some nasty little microscopic critter that found its way into my food. I really, really don't want to repeat that experience this year, so I'm going down armed with a supply of antibiotics and Gatorade powder. This year's trip is going to be a little more ambitious; we're planning a five-day hike to the lava domes at Santiaguito, and I'm going to be collecting as much clay as I can. (Why not rocks? Volcanic clay is my topic of interest at this volcano - more on that in subsequent posts.)

At any rate, I'll be out of touch for a bit, although I do promise to update when I can. In the meantime, I've scheduled a few posts about some of my subject matter, and volcanology in general. And there will be great photographs to show off when I get back!

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

A local waterfall in winter

Of course, local for me means Niagara Falls. I took a trip up on Saturday to get myself outdoors for a little while, and while I'm pretty sure no important parts of me were permanently frozen, it was effing cold up there. (Not very snowy, though. It's pretty ironic that I moved away from the Washington DC area, and they're now poised to get more snow than Buffalo this year. I think Buffalo's at about 60 inches, and if DC gets another foot or so with today's storm, they'll have us beat. Not that Buffalo is the snowiest place in New York by any means - that's Syracuse. But I digress.)

One interesting thing I found out about Niagara Falls in the winter is not only is it cold, it's damp. This is a direct result of all the spray from the Canadian and American Falls. It looks like the US gets the worst the spray off Horseshoe Falls, since the prevailing winds blow from west to east. Anyway, it makes for a somewhat hazardous visit, because everything is covered with ice.


The ice gets really thick in places, and you can see how the layers were built up. This chunk came off a light pole. It's stratification on a vertical plane!


Quite a bit of the park on the NY side was closed off, presumably because it was so slippery and they didn't want people too close to the water. 


A little artsy shot with a chunk of ice rime:


As it turns out, I have a habit of standing in almost exactly the same spots when I take photos up here. It's likely that this is just because those are the clear (and well-framed) shots, but it means I can show some neat comparisons between the winter and summer versions of Niagara Falls. As always, click to embiggen:


In the winter, because tourism is slow, the hydroelectric companies on both sides of the Niagara River restrict the water going over the Falls to about half of its full capacity (which means that around 50,000 cubic feet/second or 1,400 cubic meters/second). In the summer, somewhere around 10-25% of the flow is diverted, depending on the level of Lake Erie, which feeds the Falls.

The Canadian side really has the better views, but on the American side you get to wander around on Goat Island, which sits in between the Horseshoe (Canadian) and American Falls. Here's a couple of shots from the top of Goat Island:


Here's a brave little seagull and his favorite spot - I'm hoping the rock will be there when the ice melts!:


Looking upstream at both sets of falls:


And again:


It's pretty neat to see how things change by season. The icepack in the river gets pretty thick, so those Maid Of The Mist boats that you see going out the rest of the year are all beached, and no one goes down to the observation decks (and who'd want to get drenched in the middle of winter? Not me!)

I'll try to get a few more posts out this week, since I'm going to be in the land of sporadic internet access for the rest of the month. More on that later!

Friday, February 5, 2010

Blast from the past

On Wednesday the volcanology lab groups here at UB had a discussion about basaltic eruptions, particularly at Paricutin and Jorullo volcanoes in Mexico. The first thing I was reminded of on hearing the name Paricutin was not a geological fact, but a childhood memory - one of watching Reading Rainbow, actually.


Reading Rainbow, if you aren't familiar with it, was one of the best children's shows out there. Sadly, it ended in 2006, but in its 23 year run, host Levar Burton and any number of celebrity narrators did wonders to keep kids reading and show them that books were not only worth their time, but fun and exciting to boot. Each episode was divided between book reviews and readings - sometimes by well-known celebrities like Julia Child and James Earl Jones, to name a couple - and Levar Burton visiting people and places related to the theme of the episode. It was one show that my parents were happy to let me watch any time it was on, and they'd usually try and find the books for me to read afterward. It's sad that it's no longer going, but hopefully reruns will still pop up on public television stations.


In fact, a few of those early episodes - reruns for me, since I wasn't around to watch their first runs - were responsible for starting me on a geologic path. I particularly remember one episode called Hill of Fire, in which the featured book talked about a volcano that suddenly appeared in a Mexican cornfield - Paricutin, of course. I thought this was totally fascinating, and probably asked my parents if we could have a volcano in our backyard, or something like that. And now that I'm in graduate school, I can look back on what I remember of that show and use it as a basic context for understanding the professional papers I'm reading. How cool is that?
Another episode talked about one of my favorite childrens' book series: The Magic Schoolbus. Who doesn't love Ms. Frizzle and her crazy bus? Of course, the book was The Magic School Bus Inside the Earth, which I'm sure I made my mother go out and buy for me right afterward. These books were a great introduction to science topics, because they gave you the facts as a part of a narrative. Sneaky! Plus it's always fun to see what clothing Ms. Frizzle is going to wear next. Personally, I want some of those jumpsuits for when I do fieldwork.


Not to mention Three Days On a River In a Red Canoe. It's not about geology, but it was my first intro to camping. I didn't do any serious camping until I was in college, but this episode definitely had me out in the backyard for a few nights that summer. I have yet to take a canoe trip, however...perhaps a goal for this summer?


Obviously, these aren't the only geology/outdoors-related children's books out there, but they are a few of my favorites - and I remember them after fifteen years or so because of Reading Rainbow. 

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Hooray!

Quals are over and passed (pending some proposal rewriting and me promising to take a thermodynamics class in the near future). It's nice not having that stress hanging over my head - now I can relax and get some research done! (Not to mention getting back to blogging more often...)

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Where On (Google) Earth #181

Looks like I get to host the next episode of Where On Google Earth! Wo(G)E #180 over at Clastic Detritus turned out to be a tricky rotated image of the Farasan Banks, a huge coral reef complex off the coasts of Saudi Arabia and Yemen in the Red Sea. I don't know much about them beyond what I could dig up from a Jacques Cousteau quote:
"The wildest of all the reef complexes in the Red Sea … 350 miles long and thirty miles wide …. This demented masterpiece of outcrops, shoals, foaming reefs, and other lurking ship-breakers was created by societies of minute animals that have changed the aspect of our planet far more than man has yet been able to do."
Anyone out there a coral reef expert? At any rate, I'm sure you're all waiting for the next challenge. Here it is:



Click to zoom. No altitude or direction on this one, but hopefully there are enough clues for you to track it down. To win the round, you need to post the correct latitude and longitude in the comments below, along with a little commentary about what geological feature you're looking at. The winner gets to host the next round, or choose the location and ask someone else to host it if they're not a blogger.

To give any newcomers a head start on this one, I'll invoke the Schott Rule- you have to wait one hour after the post time to answer for each WoGE round you've one in the past. Good luck!

PS - If you want to see where Wo(G)E has gone in the past (and who's won it), take a look at Ron Schott's compilation in KMZ format!

Thursday, January 14, 2010

Richter or not?

Most of you have probably heard about the earthquake that occurred in Haiti on Tuesday. It's shaping up to be a huge disaster, especially since it occurred in an area that hasn't seen a major earthquake for centuries; when natural disasters haven't occurred within living memory, people become unprepared to deal with them. The poverty of most of the millions of Haitians who were affected has only made it worse, and it's going to be a difficult recovery for them. I encourage everyone to find a charity that will be providing aid (the Red Cross, UNICEF, Doctors Without Borders, and Direct Relief International are just a few) or donate blood through the Red Cross. Even a few dollars or a little bit of blood will help.

It's only natural that a lot of news agencies will report natural disasters, and especially large earthquakes. But over and over again, I hear even the best reports making the same mistake: using the phrase "the earthquake was an X on the Richter scale." A Google News search for "Haiti earthquake Richter" brings up more than 500 references to news articles that use that phrase. It might seem nitpicky, but it always annoys me when the media can't be bothered to use the correct phrasing to describe earthquakes - it's a small misuse of scientific terminology, but if you take a closer look at it, it's a significant one.

The Richter magnitude scale was developed in 1935 by Charles F. Richter of the California Institute of Technology based on measurements made of shallow earthquakes in California. Technically, the way it was developed means that it's the most accurate in California, and when using a specific type of seismograph; it's also not terribly accurate for very large earthquakes or distant ones. Scientists have since expanded on the methods Richter used, which now incorporate even more data that can be recorded about an earthquake. The USGS website about "Earthquake Magnitude Policy" says it this way:

"There is some confusion, however, about earthquake magnitude, primarily in the media, because seismologists often no longer follow Richter's original methodology. Richter's original methodology is no longer used because it does not give reliable results when applied to M> 7 earthquakes and it was not designed to use data from earthquakes recorded at epicentral distances greater than about 600 km. It is, therefore, useful to separate the method and the scale in releasing estimates of magnitude to the public."
As far as the USGS is concerned - and they're usually the ones reporting earthquake magnitudes to the media - the preferred method of referring to magnitudes is with moment magnitude. Again, the USGS says it pretty succinctly:
"Moment is a physical quantity proportional to the slip on the fault times the area of the fault surface that slips; it is related to the total energy released in the EQ. The moment can be estimated from seismograms (and also from geodetic measurements). The moment is then converted into a number similar to other earthquake magnitudes by a standard formula. The result is called the moment magnitude. The moment magnitude provides an estimate of earthquake size that is valid over the complete range of magnitudes, a characteristic that was lacking in other magnitude scales."
Moment magnitude is measured on a logarithmic scale - each step up is many times more powerful than the last. This means that the 7.0 earthquake that happened in Haiti is much more powerful than, say, the ~M 5 earthquake that I felt in Guatemala earlier this year. When talking about earthquakes, official reports nowadays (like the USGS press releases) say the earthquake had a "magnitude of X". This is not to be confused with earthquake intensity, which measures the strength of shaking at any particular location, and is determined mainly by the earthquake's effects on people and structures. (An earthquake rating a I on the Mercalli Intensity Scale would be so small that almost no one would feel it, while the Haiti earthquake would be a VIII or higher, with significant or total destruction and visible effects during the shaking.)


So the takeaway message is to be careful how you talk about earthquake magnitude. If the information is coming from the USGS, it's referring to moment magnitude, and not the Richter scale. Hopefully some of the media will eventually pick up on this, for accuracy's sake if nothing else. 

Tuesday, January 5, 2010

The biggest bang for your buck

Happy New Year! Having finally beaten the latest installment of the common cold, I'm back to blogging as I get ready for the new semester.


Recently there's been a bit of amusement among the geobloggers about an Paddy Power, an Irish betting website that's will take wagers on which volcano will erupt next with a VEI 3 or greater magnitude eruption. That in itself is amusing (and it would be an interesting way for grad students to fund their research, although I'm not sure it's legal). 

Doubtless, however, the folks running (and looking at) this website don't know a whole lot about the VEI system that they're basing the bets on. VEI stands for Volcanic Explosivity Index, and it's a scale that was introduced by Christopher Newhall and Stephen Self in 1982. It was originally meant to be a way to estimate the explosive magnitude of past volcanic eruptions, and combines a number of criteria:

  • Volume of material erupted (also called ejecta or tephra)
  • Height of the eruptive column
  • Qualitative descriptions (i.e., "effusive", "explosive", "paroxysmal")
  • Classification (Hawaiian, Strombolian, Vulcanian, Plinian, Ultraplinian)
  • Duration in hours
  • The most explosive type of activity observed
  • Tropospheric (up to ~10 km) and stratospheric (~10-50 km) injection of material (i.e., did the eruption column reach these atmospheric levels?

Including both quantitative and qualitative criteria allows volcanologists to evaluate eruptions that may not have been well-monitored or were only observed by non-scientists. The scale is logarithmic with respect to eruption volume; this means that a VEI 5 eruption (the size of the 1991 Pinatubo eruption, for instance) is 10 times stronger than a VEI 4 eruption (the size of the 1980 Mount St. Helens eruption). 


The VEI scale, however, is more a convenient way to describe the size of an eruption; it doesn't tell you much about the specific hazards at a volcano, because these are dependent on lots of other variables. A VEI 3 eruption at an Alaskan volcano like Redoubt is going to be a lot less hazardous than one at Mount Vesuvius, simply because Redoubt is located in such an isolated, unpopulated area and Vesuvius sits over a city of 3 million people.


(The image above is taken from the USGS Volcano Hazards Program Photo Glossary.)


Eruption forecasting in general is a tricky business. Even volcanoes that have been monitored for decades can behave in unexpected ways; if you look at things on a geologic timescale, those decades are only a blip in the volcano's history. The VEI is a great way to describe past eruptions, but the fact that a volcano has erupted with a certain magnitude doesn't necessarily mean it will do the same thing in the future. 


Of course, you're all wondering what I would place my bets on. I certainly wouldn't rank Santa Maria along with Yellowstone; while the 1902 eruption was one of the largest in the 20th century, the only activity there now is at the Santiaguito lava dome complex, and it's a little hard to compare some little Vulcanian puffs with a potential caldera eruption. I'd probably have to go with Galeras, considering the activity that's been going on there lately, but don't take my word for it. (And tempting as it would be to fund some research by betting on an eruption, I wouldn't waste my money!)


Resources:


USGS Volcano Hazards Program Photo Glossary
Ready, Steady, Blow! Volcano Betting Erupts! (Paddy Power website)
Newhall, C. and Self, S., 1982, The Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI): An Estimate of Explosive Magnitude for Historical Volcanism. Journal of Geophysical Research, v. 87, no. C2, p. 1231-1238.